
MNA Home
Back |
MUSEUM OF
NORTHERN ARIZONA
Board of Trustees Meeting
Colton House
Minutes of June 2, 2007
Board Members in Attendance:
Members Present: Susie Garretson, Chair, Sam Braun, Susan Golightly,
David Connell, Sam Henderson, Jack Metzger, Barbara Poley, Katrina
Rogers, Carolyn Shoemaker, Miguel Vasquez, Stephen Verkamp
Board Members Absent: Allan Affeldt, Rowena Dickerson, Drew
Barringer, Leigh Kuwanwisiwma, LaVelle McCoy, Beverly Miller, Peter
Pilles, Wayne Ranney, Octaviana Trujillo
Emeritus Board Members: Frances McAllister, Ben Smith (1990-98),
Susan Olberding
MNA Staff Members in Attendance: Robert Breunig, Director; Elaine
Hughes, Collections Manager, Kara Kelley, Registrar, Tracy Anderson
Sedona Muses Representative: Pat Pauli, President
Guest: Jill Korenek, JDS
Professional Services, auditor.
I. Call to Order
Chair Susie Garretson called the meeting to order at 9:20AM without a
Quorum. A quorum was reached at 9:44AM with the arrival of Jack Metzger.
II. Approval/Acceptance of Minutes
A motion to approve the Board of Trustees meeting minutes of April 7,
2007 was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
III. Approval of Consent Agenda
A motion to approve the consent agenda: Governance committee Minutes of
April 17, 2007 and May 22, 2007; Fundraising Committee Minutes of May
24, 2007; Executive Committee Meeting Minutes of May 31, 2007 was made,
seconded, and passed unanimously; Programs Committee minutes of April 7,
2007 and May 23, 2007.
IV. Report from the Chair
Susie Garretson asked all board members to send in their Board/Staff
Commitment forms. In addition, she discussed the importance of members
serving as committee chairs in the coming year; this is an important
board responsibility and she asked all to give it serious thought. Susie
reported that the Executive Committee has discussed the idea of sending
out an appreciation letter to the staff. They have also proposed a
board-hosted staff BBQ at the Colton House on August 10, 2007.
There are board photos from the April photo shoot are on a disk. Susie
will make copies for all board members and will email or send them out
by mail.
In response to an inquiry from a prospective board member, Susie wanted
all board members to know that the MNA has a two million dollar
Director’s and Officers liability insurance policy. Susie also gave
thanks to Katrina Rogers and Miguel Vasquez for their hard work and
years of service to the MNA board. Welcome to emeritus status! We will
miss them both.
v. Report from the Director
Building Assessment
Robert Breunig reported on activities following up on a discussion at
the December board meeting regarding the possible historical
significance of the five buildings to be removed for the construction of
the Collection Center. Robert reported on a meeting with Pat Stein and a
conversation by phone with the State Historic Preservation Officer. The
SHPO did encourage photo and written documentation of the buildings.
To document these and other structures of potential historic interest.
MNA has been working on a Historic Property Survey of the MNA campus
with two NAU student interns and former Board member Susan Olberding.
This survey involves the filling out of Historic Property Inventory
forms documenting all of the buildings on campus over fifty years old.
These forms will form the basis of a potential historic district
nomination for the Harold S. Colton Research Center. This project will
be reported on later in the Director’s report.
Accreditation
The museum received a letter on April 16 informing MNA of interim
accreditation. Robert read excerpts from the letter and passed around
copies. AAM will be looking closely at MNA’s long-term sustainability
and at how MNA will set priorities and scale resources in the future.
The next step in the process is a site visit by a Visiting Committee.
October will likely be the earliest that the site visit can take place
with two people appointed to visit MNA. AAM sent a list of names of
potential site reviewers to MNA for review; none were considered
problematic, so two names from this list will be selected by the AAM.
Collection Center
Robert has also been working with the Collection Center architect, Jim
Roberts regarding the environmental assessment of the buildings to be
removed for the construction of the new Collections Center. Asbestos was
found, which necessitates remediation. The estimate for this is
$45,000.00 or less. The target date to remove the buildings is
mid-August. Next steps will include 1) relocation of utilities 2)
salvage of building materials 3) the tear down and removal of the
buildings. Also needed is the installation of a 400 foot 8-inch water
line to a new fire hydrant near the new building.
Robert announced that the elevation drawings for the front of the
Collections Center displayed on the dining room table and board members
are invited to look at them. Ground breaking for the Center is expected
to take place in late summer or early fall of this year. The goal is
dedication in September 2008, the 80th birthday of the museum. Robert
also reported that MNA’s new Collection Center would offer a stable
environment for collection is the new building with minimum input of
fossil fuel. This will be achieved primarily through passive design and
proper solar orientation, insulation, the green roof, etc. Robert stated
that the head of Community Planning & Historic Preservation for the City
of Flagstaff, Karl Eberhard, said that MNA’s plan for the Collections
Center was one of the best he has seen thus far in his position with the
city.
Grants for Collection Center
MNA has received two major grants in recent months in support of
cabinetry for the new Collections Center. The first was for $250,000.00
from “Save America’s Treasures” program. The second was a $550,000.00
NEH grant for additional cabinetry, and if MNA can raise a $25,000.00
match by 2010, there will be an additional $25,000.00. Special thanks
and tribute go to Elaine Hughes, who received a letter from Charles Kolb
regarding the grant. The grant panelists confirmed “unequalled in depth
and breadth” of our collections. Therefore, to date, MNA has received
$800,000.00 for cabinetry and associated equipment. Our original
proposal to NEH was for $650,000.00; they did not grant our request for
cabinetry for natural history collections. The collections staff will be
working with conservators on a plan for packing and moving items into
the new building.
Robert read several of the peer reviewer comments from NEH reviewers
contained in a letter from NEH Program Officer Charles Kolb. It was
suggested by Susan Golightly and David Connell that MNA make Charles
Kolb’s comments widely available. Ben Smith commented that the Arizona
State Museum in Tucson recently finished a state of the art facility for
storage of over 20,000 (mostly Hohokam) artifacts and that board members
might want to visit it to get some idea of the type of storage systems
MNA will be achieving in the new collections center.
Exhibit Planning Process
Tracy Anderson, Education Director, then gave an overview and update on
MNA’s exhibits and planning process, and long-term goals for exhibits.
There is a five-year plan for exhibits, which will integrate all
programs for increased impact for the museum visitor. Short-term
exhibits are 4-6 months, intermediate term exhibits are 6-12 months, and
long-term exhibits are 12-18 months. Each mission-based theme receives
equal treatment.
She reviewed how exhibits are planned and selected. There is a proposal
evaluation process, and then internal and external reviews. MNA also
active seeks out different exhibits, such as the Namingha exhibit. There
are a rich community of educators and curators to work with, along with
community collaboration. If you have ideas on exhibits, please contact
Tracy Anderson. Robert commended Tracy on her work on the exhibits and
wanted to acknowledge her hard work.
Historic Property Survey
Susan Olberding gave a presentation on the Historic Properties Inventory
at MNA. The inventory includes the Homestead, Colton House, and all
other buildings of potential historic significance. Susan introduced,
Morgan O’Connor and Donovan Wood, the two interns who presented a slide
program on their survey. This is work was part of a History and
Preservation class n the Geography Department at NAU. They passed out a
map of MNA at this time and reviewed this history of key MNA buildings.
The project mission was to: 1) Do a physical survey and photo
documentation of all the buildings located at Coyote Range (Colton
House), the museum grounds and Research Center campus, etc. 2) The
creation of Historic Property Inventory forms for each structure. 3) The
Submission of the completed property inventory survey to the SHPO.
The survey work started in November of 2006. The ultimate goal for the
project was to explore the potential submitting a historic district
nomination to SHPO’s office and explore the potential for a nomination
of the MNA campus as a National Historic Landmark. Further objectives
were to assess the potential for funding and/or grants through the AZ
State Parks Heritage Fund, National Endowment for the Humanities,
National Preservation Endowment, and Save America’s Treasures program.
There were 34 structures to survey, ranging from administrative to
storage facilities. Twenty-five of the structures are fifty years or
older. Some interesting facts: the Potato Barn was built in 1886;
Newberry was constructed in three parts and then put together from the
pieces. Matthews Cabin was originally known as Vernon Bailey and was
move from the site of the cinder block building now known as Vernon
Bailey. All of these structures were original to Antelope Valley Ranch
that was purchased by the Colton’s for the Research Center.
David Wilcox publication
There will be a book signing at the Branigar Chase Discovery Center on
July 14 celebrating the publication of The Archaeology of Perry Mesa and
Its World by David Wilcox and Jim Holmlund. The Bilby Research Center at
NAU is the publisher.
T-Mobile Lease
In February 2007, T-Mobile approached MNA to lease land for a cell
tower. Their contract was for $12,000.00 per year, for a 15-year lease.
Patrice Hortsman has reviewed the lease agreement.
Motion: There was a recommendation for the Board to approve the idea
of the T-Mobile lease, with the final terms pending based on final
approval by the Executive Committee. The motion was made, seconded, and
passed unanimously.
Private Family Grant
Robert and staff are working on a potential $500,000.00 potential grant.
There would be $50,000.00 for the Discovery program, $25,000.00 for
operating expenses, $25,000.00 for a van and $450,000.00 for a youth
education endowment. Robert will continue to provide updates as the
process proceeds.
VI. Report of the Program Committee
The Collections staff presented a few of the following items for review
by the board:
• A circa 1942 Hopi blanket, from Dr. Robert Breunig, Karen Enyedy,
Jonathan Day and Lynn Hagan
• A Two Gray Hills rug, Robert Draper watercolor, and three pottery jars
from the Ralph Hanson Estate. The Hanson items are from a bequest to
MNA, along with other estate items that are being sold in the Museum
Shop.
• A Hopi bowl, Hopi drum made by Jimmy Kewanwytewa, and a bed headboard
and footboard. These have been given as an unrestricted gift from Sat
Best. All were owned by Dr. and Mrs. Colton and were given to Sat Best
by Denise Colton.
• A Barton Wright scratchboard of what is now the Golightly Historic
Courtyard, a painting, a plaque awarded to Ned Danson, a wooden carving
of the MNA logo awarded to Ann Hitchcock in 1971 as an award for her
teaching a museum studies class, and a small wooden box inscribed Harold
S. Colton, 1900” and containing Edward B. Danson bookplates. All were
given in memory of Jessica Danson by Ted Danson and Jan Haury.
• Rubbings of petroglyphs on cloth, photographs, and a notebook of
petroglyph site locations and drawings, from estate of Elfrieda Tingleaf.
• An Anthony Honanie painting, with a recording of an interview with
Honanie where he discusses the painting. Painting was a prizewinner from
last year’s Hopi Show, purchased by MNA.
The Collections Committee had recommended that the Danson memorabilia
items be accepted as a gift and the other items be accessioned into the
MNA Collections.
Motion: There was a recommendation for acceptance of the Collections
Committee recommendation to accept the Danson memorabilia as a gift and
that the remaining items are accessioned for MNA Collections. The motion
was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
VII. Report from the Finance and Investment Committee
David Connell gave the Finance and Investment Committee Report. He
reported that there would soon be a policy developed on using restricted
cash for short-term cash flow needs.
As for the period through April, he reported, general donations are
below what was budgeted for the period, but expenses are $88,000.00
better than plan. Over all, the budget $47,000.00 behind original
projections for the year. The Finance Committee feels that MNA might be
able to pull out this year if we are successful with additional
unrestricted donations.
A question was asked on the status of the Gift Shop sales. Gross sales
are $22,465 above budget through April, and $64,900 above last year’s
sales at this time. Director and Comptroller are reviewing discount
policies as our discounts numbers seem high. Gift Shop Manager Kalley
Keams-Lucero resigned this month. Rita Alexander has been hired as the
new Gift Shop Manager and will begin on June 11.
Motion: The Finance Committee recommended acceptance of the financial
reports for April 2007 as presented. It was seconded, and passed
unanimously.
With Kalley Lucero leaving MNA, the signature authority for the Shops
account must be modified to remove Kalley Lucero and to add Rita
Alexander to the authorized signature list for Gift Shop checks along
with Robert Breunig and Lynn Yeager. This will be effective June 11,
2007.
Motion: Motion to change the signature authority for the Shops
accounts was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
Jill Korenek, CPA with JDS Professional Group presented the audited
financials statements. JDS reported that they received full cooperation,
from staff, that all information was presented in a timely manner, and
that there were no disagreements or complications with staff during the
audit. No fraud was detected and there were no management letter
comments.
She presented the Audit Report; balances stayed relatively the same –
shifts were large promises to give went down and cash and dividends went
up. Liabilities were down $130,000.00. Line of credit was down
$200,000.00. Net assets are up .8% from prior year.
The audit report does not show the comparative figures from last year
due to the change in the fiscal year resulting in a one-time nine-month
year. Administrative fees do compare to the prior year. Classification
changes – revenue categories were changed; Science/Research, Education,
Retail, and Rental. Supplemental services are at 29% same as prior year.
This is similar to other comparable organizations. Change in net assets
is $127,000.00. JDS did not issue a “Recommendations to Management”
letter. There will be new AICPA audit standards issued. In respect to
the audit fees, JDS works with each client to hone. MNA staff will
provide documentation and help keep fees down as much as possible.
Motion: Motion to accept the January – September 2006 financial audit
from JDS Professional Group was made, seconded, and passed unanimously.
VII. Fundraising Report
The Namingha Gala event is coming up; please encourage those you know to
send in for tickets. There is a waiting list, and it will be used to
fill unused corporate tables.
For the Board of Trustees attending,
you will be contacted to discuss how you can help that evening.
The Fall Annual Appeal will be coming soon. At this October’s Board
Meeting, you may be asked to sign letters and personal notes to go out
to the membership. You can also host House Parties for new members,
reintroduce static members, etc. There are other options too, so please
contact the Fundraising Committee to discuss.
IX. Muses Report
Pat Pauli, President of the Sedona Muses had several handouts. First was
the Sedona Muses President’s report for 2006-2007. There was also a
financial statement on the Muses 2007-08 Budget, the summary of the
2006-2007 Programs, and the 2006-2007 End of Year Report.
X. Other Business
More Programs business: The future of the Ventures Program had been
discussed in the last Program Committee meeting. The program has lost
money over the past several years. Marketing has not changed
significantly over the thirty years of the program; there is increased
competition from other vendors, and increased costs (park fees,
insurance and fuel). The program has struggled financially; this year
expecting a loss of approximately $20,000.00. Options are on the table:
discontinue, continue as is or revise and expand? The Program Committee
believes this is important, and has non-financial benefits, and would
like to see the program continue. There are different options: keep the
program as it is now, ramp up marketing, etc. There is a new program
manager, Bob Hoffa, with new ideas. Susie Garretson and David Connell
originally became involved with MNA due to the Ventures Program and both
feel it has mission related benefits beyond just the financial
considerations. The Program Committee favored the option of investing
more dollars, if feasible, and staff to keep the program running next
year. The program does need help, and we hope that board members all
will put together lists of people who would be interested in the trips
and send the information to the Ventures staff.
Next meeting: Saturday, August 11, 2007; 9:00-4:00 pm; in PEARSON at
MNA .
|